Your Local Independent Insurance Agency

Personal, Commercial, and Life Insurance

Providing quality services at competitive rates. We work as an independent multiple lines agency with companies we represent to establish fair and efficient claim service for all of our clients.
John and Colette avatar

why us

See Why Our Customers Love Us

Carmen avatar


The most forward and easy-to-understand insurance group there is. We’re here to help guide you in the right direction.

Feel Supported

We have a dedicated staff here to support your every need. Led by our wonderful lead specialist, Carmen.

Credible and Reputable

With over 50 years combined experience while partnering with the top companies, we are able to assist with most insurance needs.

Quality Coverage

As Independent agents, we can quote you with multiple companies to find you the best possible coverage for what you care for most.

Edit Your Policy With Ease

Our online portal allows you to submit policy edits easily online. We change your policy and then send you a receipt of change.
get a quote now

Client Testimonials

"John and Colette Acosta researched my previous policy of both my home and vehicle and found they could save me almost double of what I had been paying. Not only was it cheaper in cost, the coverage was more! I used to have an in ground swimming pool (we had it completely removed) and I didn't realize my old insurance had never removed it from my policy! John saw that and immediately brought it to my attention. Acosta Insurance makes it easy to understand what and why they are recommending a particular insurance. I have and continue to tell everyone about Acosta Insurance. Many of my family members switched over to Acosta Insurance because of how I raved about the service I received."
"I had transferred my Insurance Company coverage plan and had helpful, friendly and attentive service with each visit. I had made credit payments at their office, which made it convenient for me. I had a minor accident with another uninsured motorist and was treated with guidance and care. I would suggest anyone with a vehicle or property that needs coverage to look into the variety of insurance companies and services that they offer."
"I'd give you 10 or more stars if I could! I will never change my insurance from John Acosta Insurance Agency, Inc. to anyone else. They are a wonderful insurance company to have for my home and car. I have even had them for a plan during a period of 6 months of a policy to tie me over until another plan came through for me in a major medical health plan. I never had to use it but it was there. They know my needs. I am very pleased and I get excellent service. Walk into their office and you'll see what I mean! They'll walk with you not on you. Very honest. The whole staff is that way."
"I have the opportunity to be able to work with the Acosta Agency on a professional and personal level and they are always professional and go out of their way to make sure all of Erie Insurance Customers are taken care of and are treated very fair and also treated like family. Then I do have my personal Insurance through the Agency and they treated us very fair and took the time to make sure we had all the coverage needed and understand the policy and endorsements that were best suited for our family. They are the best and we look forward to working with them for a long time."
what we offer

Our Insurance Services

Auto Insurance

Get quality coverage for your vehicle that will keep you fully protected while on and off the road.
View service

Home Insurance

Protect your home, one of your most valuable assets, along with all of the items stored inside for an affordable rate.
View service

Life Insurance

Be prepared for the unexpected with quality Life Insurance coverage options built to cover you and your family.
View service

Commercial/Business Insurance

From startups to full-scale operations, we've got you covered with an array of exceptional business owner policies that help you work without worry.
View service

Motorcycle Insurance

Get covered this riding season with in-depth motorcycle coverage that keeps your motorcycle safe on and off the road.
View service

Boat Insurance

Don't hit the water without fully protecting your watercraft with one of our premium boat polices today.
View service

Renters Insurance

Confidently cover all of your personal property items and your entire rental unit with ease.
View service

Rental Property Insurance

Bundle your rental properties today for ultimate savings with one of our premier dwelling fire carriers.
View service

PCL / Umbrella Insurance

Increase your general liability coverage or cover any extra gaps you may have in coverage with our extensive umbrella policy options
View service
get a quote now

Meet Our Partners

we've got you covered

Coverage With Ease


Apply Through Our Online Portal

Choose the best on for you, and you’re covered! It’s as easy as that. From here, we’re with you every step of the way.

visit the online portal
Portal step icon

Get A Personalized Quote

Choose the best on for you, and you’re covered! It’s as easy as that. From here, we’re with you every step of the way.

get quote
Quote step icon

Receive The Perfect Coverage

Choose the best on for you, and you’re covered! It’s as easy as that. From here, we’re with you every step of the way.

complete the form
Coverage step icon

client portal

Let Us Be Your Insurance Helpers!
Corey avatar
Just complete this quick and easy application and we'll get back to you as soon as possible. Looking forward to meeting you!
Get started
Start your application now!
Apply now!
How can we help?
Select the services you're applying for.
We appreciate you choosing Acosta Insurance Agency to provide you quality coverage. For a quicker and more accurate response, please feel free to fill out the extended questionnaire. This will allow us to give you a complete proposal, and offer you the most variety in coverage options.
Extended questionnaire
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
All information is secured with TLS and SSL encryptions.
Need to edit or change your current policy? Click here
John and Colette agency picture

Who we are

We're Here To Help

John and Colette have built the agency on the quality of the companies represented in the agency. This has always been important in the success of how the clients are treated in their time of need.  The agency sells for numerous insurance companies, with their main carriers being Erie Insurance Group for auto-home-business-life insurance, Indiana Farmers and AAA Insurance (Auto Club Group) for insurance and roadside assistance memberships.

28 years in business
50 years combined experience
Veteran owned
Spanish speaking
let's do this

Get Started Today

"I'm very satisfied with your whole office everyone has been a great help! Carmen is just a unique woman and always has the right answers for me!!"
Jennifer V
Acosta Insurance are great insurance agents! They are knowledgeable and handle any questions or concerns quickly.
Rolling M
Without a doubt, a magnificent treatment. Thank you, John and Carmen, for all your help, a big hug 👍
Nephtali S
Apply for a free quote
where we serve

Service Areas

Elkhart County

St. Joseph County

Hamilton County

Marshall County

Boone County

Marion County

Cass County

Tippecanoe County

Hancock County

Howard County

Hendricks County

Johnson County

Allen County

Wabash County

Don't see your area? 

If you live in Indiana and don't see your area, reach out to us and apply! We're happy to assist you.

By using this website, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts.